We had two more flavors to try: strawberry, and cherry limeade. Now the strawberry, I thought would be pretty good. The cherry limeade, I thought that that one would be pretty weird.
The strawberry ones were ok. They tasted very similar to strawberry Nestle Quik. So, as long as you are ready for that sort-of-strawberry flavor, it’s actually ok. I liked the dipped part, too. The girls were both big fans of this one.
The cherry limeade one was, well, weird. It was sour and just….well, it was weird. The girls liked it (big girl asked if it was watermelon because it looked like a watermelon and kept referring to it as watermelon even though it definitely did not taste like watermelon). But, this one was just too weird tasting for me…..but it does look pretty cool.
For this next round of Peeps taste testing, we had two of the more non-traditional flavors. Or at least one was really non-traditional (in my opinion).
First up was the vanilla one.
I like the way it looks. The sprinkles give it a bit of a funfetti look.
Now, in the last taste test, I mentioned that I was really beginning to enjoy the addition of the “dipped” element on the new Peeps. This one, however, I didn’t like very much. I thought that the dipped part had a weird taste to it. My girls, however, liked this one a lot. I think I was looking for a vanilla flavor and I didn’t really get it.
Next up, the raspberry one. I had high hopes for this one because I love all things raspberry.
This one wasn’t bad. Although, my girls and I were not in agreement on this one. I liked it, big girl liked it (I think…at least….she ate it), little girl didn’t like it so much.
The taste is a sort-of-raspberry-sort-of-berry taste. So, not full-on raspberry but still yummy.
Results: Mixed. Stay tuned for the final taste test to be posted soon……
For this next Peeps taste test, we went for the new filled varieties. I will go ahead and say that I was prepared to not like these at all. A filled Peep? It just sounds kinda gross. However, I was pleasantly surprised.
Now, the girls and I are already fans of the Peeps with the chocolate coating on the bottom. And these two varieties both have that crunchy chocolate part.
The taste? Everyone, including Ryan, liked the Triple Chocolate ones. They are chocolatey but not too chocolatey. And the chocolate filling is actually kind of light.
(please excuse my nails…..I will be repainting them soon…..)
Now, the Vanilla Caramel Brownie ones we were all a little split about. I liked them. I thought that they tasted like some kind of Starbucks Frappuccino that had been solidified into a Peeps shape. Not bad. Big girl liked this one, too. Baby girl and Ryan – not so much.
I don’t really understand the “Brownie” part of the name. But, it’s definitely got a caramel taste and that’s the main taste in the filling.
The verdict? I liked them both. I’m becoming a big fan of the chocolate on the bottom of the Peeps. The crunch is a nice addition to the soft texture of the marshmallow.
Spring is arriving and that means – Peeps! Peeps in every flavor!
Every possible flavor!
The girls were very excited to find Peeps that had been dipped in chocolate and Oreos that were Peeps flavored. Big girl was especially excited to see how many different flavors of Peeps there were this year. (That’s my kid alright!) So, we’ve decided to make this a year when we try to taste as many flavors as we can. I am not nearly as excited as the girls because I am a bigger fan of the regular ones, not necessarily the flavored ones. But, we shall see. I might just find one that I really like……and while we’re at it, the girls will eat a ton of sugar…..so that’ll be interesting too…..
We ate the chocolate covered ones and Peeps Oreos.
I will say, not all of my girls were that interested. Buddy only wanted to check them out for a few seconds and then was officially done with Peeps.
The verdict: Every loved the chocolate covered Peeps. This is actually one of my favorite non-plain Peeps. Mmmmm. Sugar with more sugar.
They are pink. Really really pink. Really, really, really pink. There were reports that the Peeps Oreos had some, um, colorful side effects. (Thankfully, that wasn’t an issue in our house.)
They are sweet. Really, really, really sweet. As pink as they are? That’s how sweet they are. And, they don’t necessarily have a Peeps or marshmallow flavor, more like a generically sweet flavor. But, they are good. And we quickly finished off that package.
First Peeps Flavor Testing Experiment: Good stuff. 🙂
Stayed tuned for taste test #2…….
I love all signs of spring. Flowers. Grass becoming greener and greener. Warmer temperatures. Swapping out coats for jackets. Buds on trees. More sunlight. Spring rain showers. And……Peeps. So many many Peeps. Chocolate dipped Peeps. Peeps on sticks. Peeps pillows. Doesn’t this just look springy to you? I am tempted to try out those new flavors but for now, I will just dream of the spring season to come.
Yes. You read that correctly. Peeps. S’Mores. O. M. G.
So, this is an example of my Pinterest wandering bringing me to something ridiculous. You know those posts of cookies stuffed with brownies? Or the Chex mix recipes that shouldn’t really be called a Chex mix anymore because they are 95% candy bar? I thought that this fell into the category, too. But something about it called out to me. Something told me that these needed to be made. So. I did. One more treat to bring to Easter.
The chocolate dipping part was super easy. The chocolate melted very well and looked great on the graham crackers with the Easter-y sprinkles. Very cute already. I set them out so the chocolate could harden.
graham cracker. white chocolate. sprinkles.
This is when I realized that the recipe said that you needed to leave your Peeps out so they could get a bit stale for easy cutting. Yep. Definitely read right over that the first time I read the recipe. So, the finished S’mores would have to wait until the next morning – one more thing to try to get done before we left.
The next day: if you are going to do these, please, for your own sanity, let the Peeps harden up for more than one night. Trying to cut these was just silly. So, the finished product is not nearly as cute as I was hoping. (Darn you, Pinterest! One more example of something not turning out as polished and perfect as yours!)
Lined up like an army of sugar.
Also, these do not travel well. The chocolate completely melted and stuck to the serving tray. So, they looked a little sad. But…..they taste really yummy! If you happen to have some leftover Peeps from Easter, I recommend giving these a try. Just try not to leave them by the window in the car.